November 16, 2026

Episode 31

Tolkien Would Hate This Podcast Part 3: Tolkien vs. The Machine (AI)

Hosts & Guests

Alicia

Alicia

(she/they) A queer Tolkien scholar and Zelda nerd interested in adaptation, audience reception, and biography.

Grace

Grace

(she/her) An acquirer of books, a queer-rights activist, serves as as the Subscriptions Steward of the Mythopoeic Society, and is a Professional Nerd (okay, technically it’s an unpaid internship).

Leah

Leah

(she/her) Just another weird Tolkien geek living in the Grey Havens (also known as Seattle WA) with two rabbits and far too few books.

Tim

Tim

(he/him) An experienced podcaster, Online Events Steward for the Mythopoeic Society, all-around nerd, and firmly believes that if more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world.

Resources

AI Impacts:
Copyright:

AI Litigation Tracker

Judge approves a $1.5B Anthropic settlement over pirated books used to train the Claude chatbot

Bartz book authors, Anthropic announce terms of proposed class action settlement. At least $1.5 billion. Destroy pirated book copies. Fair or foul?

Labor:

‘In the end, you feel blank’: India’s female workers watching hours of abusive content to train AI

Genocide in Gaza/Iran War Crimes:

U.S. military is using AI to help plan Iran air attacks, sources say, as lawmakers call for oversight

Anthropic’s Claude AI being used in Iran war by U.S. military, sources say

AI Is Already Being Used to Kill Palestinians in Gaza

Anduril’s AI System Deployed in Middle East Conflict for Drone Defense

Iran school bombing: grounds to believe US was behind atrocity, UN finds

Department of Defense Contracts:

OpenAI’s Pentagon Deal: What the Classified Military AI Agreement Binds

Trump orders US agencies to stop using Anthropic technology in clash over AI safety

ICE, State and Local Law Enforcement and Surveillance:

Scars, Tattoos, And License Plates: This Is What Palantir And The LAPD Know About You

Predictive Policing in LA: LAPD Employs Palantir for Surveillance

Rise of the Killer Chatbots

Anthropic Is Building a Predictive Surveillance System to Monitor Activists

Cybersecurity/Hacking/Attacks on Other Companies:

Anthropic’s Claude AI escapes to hack into three organisations

An OpenAI test model escaped and broke into a real company’s servers

Researchers used Anthropic’s Claude to hack into OpenAI

Anthropic AI used fake profiles to target people in hack then hid the evidence

Scientists have found an alarming environmental impact of vast data centers

Data Centers, Pollution, and the Communities Left Behind

The carbon and water footprints of data centers and what this could mean for artificial intelligence

The dark side of AI — shocking report reveals 11 planned AI data centers connected to OpenAI, Meta and Microsoft could produce more greenhouse gases than Morocco

State reveals full DRI report on OpenAI’s Effingham County data center project

Anthropic Goes Big in Australia: 2.16 GW Data Center Will Power Claude

Public Health:

ChatGPT’s medical advice nearly killed a Florida man, lawsuit against OpenAI claims

Mushrooming Misinformation: Generative AI Poses Deadly Threat 

Generative AI and misinformation: a scoping review of the role of generative AI in the generation, detection, mitigation, and impact of misinformation

Unveiling the Veiled Threat: The Impact of Bots on COVID-19 Health Communication

AI misinformation has set back pandemic preparedness

Synthetic Lies: Understanding AI-Generated Misinformation and Evaluating Algorithmic and Human Solutions

Teenage AI Meat Proxy Stranded on “Widowmaker” Mountain After Following AI Instructions

Social and Psychological Health:

OpenAI faces 7 lawsuits claiming ChatGPT drove people to suicide, delusions

ChatGPT Lawsuits for Suicide & Self Harm (2026)

Social Media Victims Law Center and Tech Justice Law Project lawsuits accuse ChatGPT of emotional manipulation, supercharging AI delusions, and acting as a “suicide coach”

OpenAI asks California court to dismiss lawsuits over Tumbler Ridge shooting

He Had a Mental Breakdown Talking to Chat GPT. Then Police Killed Him

People Are Losing Loved Ones to Ai-fueled Spiritual Fantasies

Minds in Crisis: How the AI Revolution is Impacting Mental Health

Cult of Anthropic Insiders Rumored to Be Worshipping Claude as a God

AI Now Claiming to Be God

Your AI chatbot keeps agreeing with you. Researchers say that could be a problem

About This Episode

AI has been a hot topic in the Tolkien world in recent months, with many strong opinions expressed. In an episode we probably should have done a long time ago, Leah takes Grace, Alicia, and #1 Tolkien AI Hater Tim on a journey through some of the major players in Generative and Agentic AI, including those that have co-opted Tolkienian names, and we critically examine Tolkien’s writings on technology and machine-generated goods and content. We cover some background on different types of AI technologies, the myriad of issues and concerns surrounding them, Tolkien’s thoughts on technology and its capabilities via his letters and satirical writings, and finally how technology is portrayed within his Legendarium, all to ultimately address the question “How would JRRT feel about AI?”. Settle in for an episode full of uncomfortable laughter at the horrors of AI and end-stage capitalism, but which ends with some hopeful calls to action on how you can resist AI ubiquity and reflect Tolkien’s attitudes around technology in your own life and the spaces you occupy.

Content warnings: War, death, CSAM, suicide, psychosis

Related Episodes

Episode 30 – Acespec JTR Issue with Editors Clare & Rory

Episode 30 – Acespec JTR Issue with Editors Clare & Rory

Episode 27 Acespec JTR Issue with Editors Clare & Rory Hosts & GuestsClare Moore is a PhD student at the University Glasgow researching disability in Tolkien’s fiction. (they/them) is a plant scientist, folk musician, Tolkien nerd, and ethnobotanist (of both...

Episode 29 – The Carpenter Biography: A Response

Episode 29 – The Carpenter Biography: A Response

Episode 29 The Carpenter Biography: A Response Hosts & Guests(she/they) A queer Tolkien scholar and Zelda nerd interested in adaptation, audience reception, and biography. (she/her) An acquirer of books, a queer-rights activist, serves as as the Subscriptions...